Edmonton or Calgary: Which Alberta City is Calling Your Name?
Explore Edmonton and Calgary's job markets, housing, and lifestyle to find your ideal Alberta city. Discover which city calls to your soul.
December 16, 2024
Edmonton or Calgary: Which Alberta City is Calling Your Name?
Alberta, with its majestic mountains and undeniable Canadian spirit, is calling your name. But when it comes to choosing between Edmonton and Calgary, the decision can be tough. Both cities offer unique charms and opportunities, making the Edmonton vs Calgary debate a common dilemma for those seeking a new home. Fear not, fellow adventurers! This guide will help you navigate the Edmonton vs Calgary conundrum, comparing everything from job markets and housing to lifestyle and outdoor adventures. By the end, you'll be confident in choosing the Alberta city that's truly your perfect match.
Job Market and Economic Outlook
Alberta's economy has traditionally been fueled by its rich natural resources, particularly oil and gas. However, both Edmonton and Calgary are actively diversifying, creating exciting new opportunities in various sectors.
Edmonton, Alberta's capital city, boasts a diverse economy with strengths in government, healthcare, education, and technology. The city is also a major hub for the energy sector, though it's been actively diversifying in recent years. According to Edmonton's Economic Development Strategy [invalid URL removed], key growth sectors include health innovation, artificial intelligence, and clean technology. The average weekly earnings in Edmonton are approximately $1,279, with the highest wages found in the mining, quarrying, and oil and gas extraction sector (source: Alberta Economic Dashboard).
Calgary, on the other hand, is renowned as the "Energy Capital of Canada," with a strong presence of oil and gas companies. However, Calgary is also making strides in technology, finance, and tourism. Calgary Economic Development reports that the city's key sectors include innovation and technology, transportation and logistics, and agribusiness. The average weekly earnings in Calgary are slightly higher than in Edmonton, at around $1,326, with the highest wages also found in the energy sector (source: Alberta Economic Dashboard).
Lifestyle and Cultural Scene
Beyond the job market, choosing between Edmonton and Calgary often comes down to your preferred lifestyle. Both cities offer a high quality of life, but their vibes and cultural scenes differ in distinct ways.
Edmonton, with its friendly and down-to-earth atmosphere, often feels like a big small town. It's known for its strong sense of community, affordable living, and easy access to nature. The city boasts a thriving arts and culture scene, with numerous theaters, museums, and galleries. Edmonton is also a festival city, hosting events like the Edmonton Folk Music Festival (Edmonton Folk Music Festival website) and the Fringe Theatre Festival (Edmonton International Fringe Theatre Festival website) throughout the year. For those who love to dine out, Edmonton offers a diverse culinary scene, with everything from casual pubs and ethnic eateries to upscale restaurants. While the city may not have the same concentration of Michelin-starred restaurants as some larger metropolises, it offers a wide variety of flavors and price points to satisfy any palate. You can find everything from authentic Vietnamese pho at Pho Tau Bay to modern Canadian cuisine at Corso 32 (Corso 32 website).
Calgary, on the other hand, has a more metropolitan feel, with a faster pace of life and a focus on business and industry. The city's downtown core is bustling with activity, and its nightlife scene is more vibrant than Edmonton's, with a wider array of bars, clubs, and late-night entertainment options. Calgary is also home to world-class attractions like the Calgary Stampede (Calgary Stampede website), the Calgary Zoo (Calgary Zoo website), and Studio Bell, home of the National Music Centre (Studio Bell website). When it comes to shopping, Calgary boasts major shopping malls like Chinook Centre (Chinook Centre website) and CrossIron Mills (CrossIron Mills website), as well as a thriving independent boutique scene in neighborhoods like Inglewood and Kensington.
In terms of music and entertainment, both cities have something to offer. Edmonton is known for its live music scene, with venues like the Winspear Centre (Winspear Centre website) and the Jubilee Auditorium (Northern Alberta Jubilee Auditorium website) hosting a variety of concerts and performances. Calgary's music scene is equally diverse, with venues like the Southern Alberta Jubilee Auditorium (Southern Alberta Jubilee Auditorium website) and the Jack Singer Concert Hall attracting renowned artists. Both cities also have thriving theater communities, with professional and amateur productions showcasing a range of genres.
For sports enthusiasts, both cities have professional teams to cheer for. Edmonton is home to the Oilers (NHL) (Edmonton Oilers website) and the Elks (CFL) (Edmonton Elks website), while Calgary boasts the Flames (NHL) (Calgary Flames website) and the Stampeders (CFL) (Calgary Stampeders website). Both cities also have numerous community centers and recreational facilities, offering opportunities to participate in a variety of sports and activities.
Ultimately, the best city for you depends on your personal preferences and priorities. If you value a strong sense of community, a relaxed pace of life, and easy access to nature, Edmonton might be the better fit. If you prefer a more bustling urban environment with a vibrant nightlife and a wider range of entertainment options, Calgary could be the city for you.
Housing and Neighborhoods
Whether you're seeking a cozy condo, a spacious family home, or a trendy loft, both Edmonton and Calgary offer diverse housing options to suit various needs and budgets. However, there are some key differences in their real estate markets and neighborhood characteristics.
In Edmonton, the average home price is generally lower than in Calgary, making it a more affordable option for first-time homebuyers or those seeking more space for their money. According to the Realtors Association of Edmonton, the average single-family home price in Edmonton is around $475,000, while condos average around $250,000. You can find a variety of housing styles, from charming character homes in mature neighborhoods like Glenora (where prices typically start around $600,000) and Westmount (with averages closer to $800,000) to modern condos and townhouses in developing areas like Windermere (where you might find townhouses for $400,000 and condos for $300,000) and Griesbach (with newer builds starting around $500,000). Edmonton's neighborhoods also tend to be more spread out, with larger lot sizes and a greater emphasis on single-family homes.
Calgary's housing market is more competitive, with higher average home prices and a faster-paced real estate scene. The Calgary Real Estate Board reports the average single-family home price in Calgary is around $600,000, while condos average around $300,000. The city offers a mix of housing options, from trendy inner-city condos and townhouses to sprawling suburban estates. Calgary's neighborhoods are often more densely populated, with a greater mix of housing types and a focus on walkability and urban amenities. Popular neighborhoods include the Beltline, with its vibrant mix of shops, restaurants, and nightlife (expect to pay upwards of $400,000 for a condo and $700,000 for a townhouse); Kensington, known for its trendy boutiques and cafes (where detached homes can easily exceed $1 million); and Inglewood, a historic district with a thriving arts scene (where renovated character homes often start around $800,000).
Outdoor Recreation and Natural Beauty
For those who love the great outdoors, both Edmonton and Calgary offer incredible access to natural beauty and recreational opportunities. Whether you're an avid hiker, a skier, a kayaker, or simply enjoy spending time in nature, you'll find plenty to explore in both cities.
Edmonton is known for its extensive river valley park system, which stretches for over 22 kilometers and offers over 160 kilometers of trails for walking, cycling, and cross-country skiing. The North Saskatchewan River winds its way through the city, providing opportunities for kayaking, canoeing, and paddleboarding. Just outside the city limits, you'll find Elk Island National Park, a haven for wildlife viewing and hiking, and the Cooking Lake-Blackfoot Provincial Recreation Area, with its beaches, campgrounds, and trails.
Calgary is nestled in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains, offering breathtaking scenery and easy access to world-class skiing, hiking, and climbing. Banff National Park, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, is just a 90-minute drive from the city, offering stunning mountain vistas, turquoise lakes, and abundant wildlife. Kananaskis Country, another popular outdoor destination, is even closer, with opportunities for hiking, mountain biking, fishing, and camping. Within the city limits, Calgary boasts Fish Creek Provincial Park, one of the largest urban parks in North America, with over 100 kilometers of trails and diverse natural habitats.
Education and Healthcare
When choosing a city to call home, access to quality education and healthcare is a top priority for many, especially families. Both Edmonton and Calgary boast excellent educational institutions and healthcare systems, but there are some key differences to consider.
Edmonton is home to several renowned post-secondary institutions, including the University of Alberta (consistently ranked among the top 5 universities in Canada), MacEwan University (known for its strong arts and humanities programs), and NAIT (Northern Alberta Institute of Technology), a leading polytechnic school. The city also has a well-regarded public school system, with a variety of programs and options to suit diverse learning needs. Edmonton Public Schools and Edmonton Catholic Schools are the two main school boards, offering a range of specialized programs, such as language immersion, fine arts, and gifted education. For families with young children, Edmonton offers a range of childcare options, from licensed daycare centers to preschool programs.
Calgary also boasts a strong education sector, with the University of Calgary (another top-ranked university in Canada, particularly known for its engineering and medical programs), Mount Royal University (a comprehensive undergraduate institution), and SAIT (Southern Alberta Institute of Technology), a leading polytechnic school. The city's public school system is also highly regarded, with a focus on innovation and student success. The Calgary Board of Education and the Calgary Catholic School District offer a variety of programs and services, including alternative learning programs, early childhood education, and specialized supports for students with diverse needs. Calgary offers a variety of childcare options, including daycare centers, preschools, and in-home care.
In terms of healthcare, both cities have access to excellent medical facilities and services. Edmonton is home to the University of Alberta Hospital, one of the largest and most advanced hospitals in Canada, specializing in areas like cardiac care, transplant surgery, and oncology. Calgary boasts the Foothills Medical Centre, another leading healthcare facility, known for its expertise in trauma care, neurosurgery, and cardiac sciences. Both cities also have a network of community health centers and clinics, providing accessible primary care and specialized services.
While both cities offer comprehensive healthcare, there can be differences in wait times for certain procedures and specialist appointments. For example, according to the Fraser Institute's wait time report, the median wait time for elective surgery in Edmonton is slightly shorter than in Calgary. However, wait times for specific procedures can vary depending on the specialty and the urgency of the case.
Both cities also offer a range of mental health services and supports. Edmonton has the Canadian Mental Health Association - Edmonton Region (CMHA Edmonton), which provides a variety of programs and resources for individuals and families affected by mental health issues. Calgary has the Calgary Distress Centre, which offers 24/7 crisis support, counselling, and referrals.
Transportation and Infrastructure
Getting around with ease is essential for daily life, whether you're commuting to work, exploring the city, or venturing further afield. Both Edmonton and Calgary have well-developed transportation networks, but they differ in terms of their public transit systems, road networks, and airport accessibility.
Edmonton boasts an extensive public transportation system, with the Edmonton Transit Service (ETS) operating buses and the LRT (Light Rail Transit) system. The LRT connects major destinations throughout the city, including downtown, the University of Alberta, and NAIT. Edmonton also has a growing network of bike lanes and pathways, making it increasingly friendly for cyclists. However, the city's sprawling layout means that owning a car can be convenient for those who live in the suburbs or need to travel frequently outside the city center. Commute times in Edmonton can vary depending on the distance and mode of transportation, but the average commute time is around 25 minutes, according to Statistics Canada. Public transit fares are reasonable, with a monthly pass costing $100 for adults.
Calgary's public transportation system, Calgary Transit, also operates buses and a CTrain LRT system. The CTrain network is more extensive than Edmonton's LRT, with lines extending to the north, south, and west of the city center. Calgary also has a well-developed road network, with major highways like Deerfoot Trail and Stoney Trail providing efficient connections throughout the city and surrounding areas. However, traffic congestion can be a challenge during peak hours, particularly on major routes. The average commute time in Calgary is slightly higher than in Edmonton, at around 28 minutes, according to Statistics Canada. A monthly transit pass for Calgary Transit costs $109 for adults.
When it comes to air travel, both cities have international airports. Edmonton International Airport (EIA) offers a wide range of domestic and international flights, with connections to major hubs across Canada and the United States. Calgary International Airport (YYC) is a larger airport with a broader selection of international destinations, including direct flights to Europe and Asia.
Community and Family Life
Both Edmonton and Calgary are known for their friendly and welcoming communities, making them attractive destinations for families and individuals seeking a sense of belonging. However, the social atmosphere and family-oriented activities can differ between the two cities.
Edmonton has a reputation for being a down-to-earth and community-minded city, where people are quick to lend a helping hand and connect with their neighbors. The city boasts numerous community leagues and organizations that offer a variety of programs and events, from sports and recreation to arts and culture. Edmonton also has a strong family focus, with many parks, playgrounds, and family-friendly attractions. The city's lower cost of living can also make it an appealing option for families, as it allows for more disposable income to spend on activities and experiences.
Calgary also has a strong sense of community, with a diverse population and a welcoming atmosphere. The city's vibrant downtown core offers a range of social opportunities, from trendy cafes and restaurants to bustling bars and nightclubs. Calgary also has a variety of family-friendly attractions, including the Calgary Zoo, the Calgary Science Centre, and Heritage Park Historical Village. However, the city's higher cost of living can be a factor for families, especially those with young children who require childcare.
The Verdict: Finding Your Perfect Fit
So, which Alberta city reigns supreme? As with most things in life, the answer is: it depends! Both Edmonton and Calgary offer unique advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice for you hinges on your individual priorities and lifestyle preferences.
If you're seeking a more affordable city with a strong sense of community and easy access to nature, Edmonton might be the perfect fit. Its diverse economy, family-friendly atmosphere, and abundance of outdoor recreation opportunities make it an attractive destination for those seeking a balanced lifestyle.
On the other hand, if you crave a bustling city with a vibrant cultural scene, a thriving business environment, and close proximity to the Rocky Mountains, Calgary could be your ideal match. Its strong economy, diverse neighborhoods, and world-class attractions offer something for everyone.
Ultimately, the best way to decide is to consider your own needs and priorities. What are your must-haves in a city? What kind of lifestyle do you envision for yourself and your family? By carefully weighing the pros and cons of each city, you can make an informed decision that sets you up for success and happiness in your new Alberta home.
Ready to embark on your Alberta adventure?
Whether you choose Edmonton or Calgary, MTS Moving is here to make your relocation smooth and stress-free. Our experienced team can handle all the logistics, from packing and transportation to storage and insurance. Contact us today for a free quote and let us help you make your move to your perfect Alberta city a reality!